Comparative Study to Evaluate Mixing Efficiency of Very Fine Particles

Abstract

This study evaluates the applicability and accuracy of coarse-grain modeling (CGM) in discrete-element method (DEM)-based simulations, focusing on particle-mixing efficiency in five representative industrial mixers: the tumbling V mixer, ribbon-blade mixer, paddle-blade mixer, vertical-blade mixer, and conical-screw mixer. Although the DEM is widely employed for particulate system simulations, the high computational cost associated with fine particles significantly hinders large-scale applications. CGM addresses these issues by scaling up particle sizes, thereby reducing particle counts and allowing longer simulation timesteps. We utilized the Lacey mixing index (LMI) as a statistical measure to quantitatively assess mixing uniformity across various CGM scaling factors. Based on the results, CGM significantly reduced computational time (by over 90% in certain cases) while preserving acceptable accuracy levels in terms of LMI values. The mixing behaviors remained consistent under various CGM conditions, based on both visually inspected particle distributions and the temporal LMI trends. Although minor deviations occurred in early-stage mixing, these discrepancies diminished with time, with the final LMI errors remaining below 5% in most scenarios. These findings indicate that CGM effectively enhances computational efficiency in DEM simulations without significantly compromising physical accuracy. This research provides practical guidelines for optimizing industrial-scale particle-mixing processes and conducting computationally feasible, scalable, and reliable DEM simulations.