Exploring 3D community inconsistency in human chromosome contact networks

Abstract

Researchers have developed chromosome capture methods such as Hi-C to better understand DNA's 3D folding in nuclei. The Hi-C method captures contact frequencies between DNA segment pairs across the genome. When analyzing Hi-C data sets, it is common to group these pairs using standard bioinformatics methods (e.g. PCA). Other approaches handle Hi-C data as weighted networks, where connected node pairs represent DNA segments in 3D proximity. In this representation, one can leverage community detection techniques developed in complex network theory to group nodes into mesoscale communities containing nodes with similar connection patterns. While there are several successful attempts to analyze Hi-C data in this way, it is common to report and study the most typical community structure. But in reality, there are often several valid candidates. Therefore, depending on algorithm design, different community detection methods focusing on slightly different connectivity features may have differing views on the ideal node groupings. In fact, even the same community detection method may yield different results if using a stochastic algorithm. This ambiguity is fundamental to community detection and shared by most complex networks whenever interactions span all scales in the network. This is known as community inconsistency. This paper explores this inconsistency of 3D communities in Hi-C data for all human chromosomes. We base our analysis on two inconsistency metrics, one local and one global, and quantify the network scales where the community separation is most variable. For example, we find that TADs are less reliable than A/B compartments and that nodes with highly variable node-community memberships are associated with open chromatin. Overall, our study provides a helpful framework for data-driven researchers and increases awareness of some inherent challenges when clustering Hi-C data into 3D communities.