형사소송법상 재심개시절차 규정의 개선방안- 최근 일본형사소송법 개정을 계기로 -

Proposals on Provisions for Procedures of Commencing a Retrial under the Criminal Procedure Act

초록

Various issues have been pointed out regarding the procedure for commencing a retrial prescribed in Article 420 et seq. of the Criminal Procedure Act. For instances, these include procedural delays resulting from the recognition of the immediate complaints by prosecutor against a decision of ruling for commencing reopening of procedure, and the difficulty of conducting an effective hearing because, while investigation of facts in these proceedings is left entirely to the judge’s discretion, the inspection of evidence is not permitted. In this regard, Japan amended its Criminal Procedure Act in 2026 to revise the regulations governing the process of commencing reopening of procedure. Since Japan’s retrial procedure is very similar to our system—in that it adopts a two-stage structure and permits retrials only when they are in the defendant’s interest—the recent amendments in Japan provide significant insights for our legislative discussions. Based on the discussions regarding the amendment to Japan’s Criminal Procedure Act, this paper proposes legislative improvements centered on the need to introduce provisions regarding inspection of facts and discovery; the need to repeal the provision allowing prosecutors to file an immediate complaint against a ruling for commencing reopening of procedure; furthermore, the need to appoint a court-appointed defense counsel in certain cases.

키워드

재심; 재심개시절차; 증거개시; 즉시항고; 국선변호인; Court-Appointed Defense Counsel; Discovery; Immediate Complaint; Procedure for Commencing a Retrial; Retrial
제목
형사소송법상 재심개시절차 규정의 개선방안- 최근 일본형사소송법 개정을 계기로 -
제목 (타언어)
Proposals on Provisions for Procedures of Commencing a Retrial under the Criminal Procedure Act
저자
송주용
DOI
10.17008/skklr.2026.38.3.011
발행일
2026-09
유형
Y
저널명
성균관법학
권
38
호
3
페이지
389 ~ 421