상세 보기
『담헌서』「율관해」·「변율」의 계산 구조 연구 - 『주해수용』과의 비교를 통하여 -
초록
This study analyzes the computational structure underlying the derivation of the twelve pitch pipes and variant pitches in “Yulgwanhae” (律管解) and “Byeonyul” (變律), included in Hong Dae-yong’s (洪大容) Damheonseo (湛軒書). It first examines the issues concerning the establishment of Hwangjong (黃鍾) raised in “Hwangjong Gogeum Idong Jiui” (黃鍾古今異同之議), and then uses Juhaesuyong (籌解需用) as the primary comparative source and Surijeongon (數理精蘊) as a supplementary reference for a typological comparison of computational procedures. In “Hwangjong Gogeum Idong Jiui,” Hong Dae-yong examines the limitations of existing methods for establishing Hwangjong, particularly the problem of discarding remainders generated in the process of sambun sonik (三分損益). A comparison of “Yulgwanhae” and “Byeonyul” with Juhaesuyong reveals corresponding structures in proportional calculation, the treatment of fractions and remainders, and volume calculation. In particular, “Yulgwanhae” designates remainders resulting from non-exact division as giryeong (畸零), retains them as fractions, and carries them forward into subsequent calculations. In “Byeonyul,” the computational procedures found in “Yulgwanhae” are extended beyond the twelve pitches to derive six variant pitches, from byeon-Hwangjong (變黃鍾) to byeon-Eungjong (變應鍾). This range corresponds to the six variant pitches presented in Cai Yuanding’s Yullyeo Sinseo (律呂新書), although the two works differ in their treatment of remainders. Cai Yuanding multiplies the numerical value of Jungnyeo (仲呂) by 729 to carry out six successive sambun sonik operations and subsequently records the remainders, whereas Hong Dae-yong continues the calculation in fractional form by multiplying the denominator by three at each stage. No extant record, however, directly explains why Hong Dae-yong stopped the calculation after byeon-Eungjong. This analysis shows that the derivation of the twelve pitch pipes and variant pitches in “Yulgwanhae” and “Byeonyul” follows a structure in which proportional calculation, the treatment of fractions and remainders, and volume calculation are repeated and extended through a consistent computational procedure. This provides a basis for understanding Hong Dae-yong’s theory of musical temperament from the perspective of its computational structure.
키워드
- 제목
- 『담헌서』「율관해」·「변율」의 계산 구조 연구 - 『주해수용』과의 비교를 통하여 -
- 제목 (타언어)
- A Study of the Computational Structure of “Yulgwanhae” and “Byeonyul” in Damheonseo: A Comparison with Juhaesuyong
- 저자
- 심지우
- 발행일
- 2026-10
- 유형
- Y
- 저널명
- 국악원논문집
- 호
- 54
- 페이지
- 151 ~ 172
- 언어
- KOR
- 출판사
- 국립국악원
- 분량
- 22 페이지
- ISSN
- P 1225-7796