신속성 시각에서 의료감정과 법원의 합리적 관계 구축에 관한 민사소송법적 소고

A Civil Procedure Law Study on Establishing a Rational Relationship Between Medical Appraisals and the Court from the Perspective of Expediency

초록

Medical appraisals are a key element in connecting medical expertise to judicial procedures in medical disputes. Despite this, medical appraisals are often criticized for their limitations, such as widespread litigation delays due to prolonged appraisal response times. Therefore, discussions on rational improvements to medical appraisals are urgently needed. Previous research on medical appraisals is significant in that it examines them from various specific perspectives. However, research examining the relationship between medical appraisals and the courts has been relatively limited. Therefore, this study focused on speed and conducted research on this topic. We also examined medical appraisals in the US, Germany, and Japan, focusing on speed and deriving implications for our own medical appraisals. Based on these insights, the following are the key points discussed regarding the relationship between medical appraisals and the courts from a speed perspective. Regarding the introduction of an AI-based electronic appraisal system, first, the introduction of an AI-based electronic appraisal system is initially reasonable to address the limitations of the current medical appraisal system, such as delays and returns. Second, AI automation is a viable option to overcome limitations such as missing appraisal data when drafting appraisal requests. Third, by incorporating AI/ML-based data decision-making technology into the AI ​​electronic appraisal request system, the automated medical appraisal acceptance methodology implemented through this system can address issues such as the difficulty of confirming individual medical appraisers' schedules. Fourth, the introduction of the AI ​​electronic appraisal request system poses a risk of leakage of personal information, such as the subject's name and various medical records (e.g., medical diagnoses) due to external attacks. Therefore, the introduction of a consortium blockchain system is a reasonable option for this system. Regarding the regulation of medical appraisal submission deadlines and appraisal fee increases, first, the AI ​​electronic appraisal request system can automatically set a three-month response deadline with a one-month extension. Second, it would be reasonable to establish a system that automatically prompts appraisers when the corresponding deadline has passed. Third, while the recent fee increase policy has some merit, it requires continued reconsideration, as it presents a greater financial burden for plaintiffs with financial disadvantages, such as those performing medical evaluations with a high number of questions. In Germany, the introduction of "publicly appointed and sworn (öffentlich bestellte und vereidigte) appraisers" (public appraisers) demonstrates the rationality of overcoming the current rejection and delay of medical evaluations from a speedy perspective.

키워드

감정; 의료감정; 신속성 시각에서의 의료감정; 의료감정과 법원의 합리적 관계; AI 전자감정촉탁시스템 도입 방안; AI/ML 기반 AI 전자감정촉탁시스템 접목방안; AI 전자감정촉탁시스템에의 컨소시엄 블록체인 도입방안; AI 전자감정촉탁시스템에서 자동적 감정 회신 기한 설정방안; AI 자동 독촉 시스템 구축방안; 독일의 ‘공적으로 선임되며 선서한(öffentlich bestellte und vereidigte) 감정인’ 도입방안; Appraisal; medical appraisal; medical appraisal from the perspective of speed; rational relationship between medical appraisal and court; introduction plan of AI electronic appraisal request system; integration plan of AI/ML-based AI electronic appraisal request system; introduction plan of consortium blockchain to AI electronic appraisal request system; automatic appraisal response deadline setting plan in AI electronic appraisal request system; establishment plan of AI automatic demand system; introduction plan of ‘publicly appointed and sworn (öffentlich bestellte und vereidigte) appraisers’ in Germany
제목
신속성 시각에서 의료감정과 법원의 합리적 관계 구축에 관한 민사소송법적 소고
제목 (타언어)
A Civil Procedure Law Study on Establishing a Rational Relationship Between Medical Appraisals and the Court from the Perspective of Expediency
저자
이찬양
DOI
10.17007/klaj.2026.75.2.011
발행일
2026-04
유형
Y
저널명
법조
권
75
호
2
페이지
363 ~ 400