철강 제조공정별 특허 분석을 통한 철강 로봇기술 경쟁력 및 유망 기술영역 도출

A Study on Identifying Competitiveness in Steelmaking Robot Technology and Promising Technology Areas through Patent Analysis by Manufacturing Process

초록

This study aims to analyze patent trends and process-specific patent competitiveness in robotics and robot-based automation technologies applied to steel manufacturing processes and to provide a quantitative basis for future technology development and patent strategies. For this purpose, a total of 2,207 valid patent records were collected and refined from IP5 jurisdictions (South Korea, the United States, Japan, Europe, and China) and PCT international applications covering the period from 1976 to 2025. The analysis focused on annual and jurisdiction-level patent filing trends, technology market growth stages, process-specific patent distributions, major applicants, the Activity Index (AI), Cites Per Patent (CPP), Patent Family Size (PFS), Patent Impact Index (PII), Technology Strength (TS), patent filing concentration measured by CR4 and HHI, and process-specific patent competitiveness. The results are as follows. First, patent filings related to steel robotics began to increase substantially after 2008, and overall patent activity exhibited the characteristics of a “growth stage.” China accounted for 1,685 of the 2,207 analyzed patent filings (76.3%), representing the largest share in terms of filing volume. China, South Korea, and Japan showed relatively high proportions of domestic first applicants, whereas the United States and Europe showed relatively higher proportions of foreign first applicants, indicating differences in patent filing structures across jurisdictions. Second, rolling accounted for the largest share of patent filings, with 939 cases (42.5%), followed by ironmaking with 586 cases (26.6%), steelmaking with 459 cases (20.8%), and post-processing with 223 cases (10.1%). Rolling also showed the highest patent filing share across the major jurisdictions, while patent filings across the manufacturing processes showed a long-term increasing trend. Major applicants, including China Baowu Group, the University of Science and Technology Beijing (USTB), Nippon Steel Corporation, Shougang Group, and SMS group, showed relatively high filing shares in rolling. In contrast, POSCO Holdings and JFE Steel Corporation exhibited broader patent distributions across multiple manufacturing processes. Third, the combined CPP-PFS analysis showed that the United States, South Korea, and Japan had both above-average citation impact and broader overseas patent protection. At the process level, rolling showed above-average values for both indicators. Steelmaking exhibited relatively high citation impact but a narrower scope of overseas patent protection, whereas ironmaking and post-processing showed below-average values for both indicators. Fourth, the CR4-HHI analysis showed that South Korea had the highest patent filing concentration, with an HHI of 2,703.21, indicating that patent activity was relatively concentrated among a limited number of major applicants. China, Japan, the United States, Europe, and PCT applications showed lower concentration levels than South Korea. At the process level, all four manufacturing processes exhibited relatively dispersed patent filing structures. Fifth, the patent-indicator-based comprehensive evaluation classified rolling as “high,” steelmaking and post-processing as “medium,” and ironmaking as “low.” Rolling showed the largest overall patent filing volume and relatively strong performance in qualitative patent indicators. Steelmaking showed comparatively stronger qualitative competitiveness, particularly in citation impact and technological impact, despite relatively weaker recent quantitative patent activity. Ironmaking showed an increase in recent patent activity, while post-processing maintained relatively stable patent activity; however, both processes showed comparatively weaker qualitative patent indicators. These findings demonstrate that patent activity and patent competitiveness in steel robotics differ across jurisdictions, applicants, and manufacturing processes. In particular, this study extends existing domestic research on steel-related patent analysis by classifying steel manufacturing into ironmaking, steelmaking, rolling, and post-processing and by comparatively analyzing robotics- and automation-related patents across these processes. Accordingly, future technology development and patent strategies should be differentiated by process. A selective approach should be adopted in rolling in consideration of the existing level of patent competition. In steelmaking, existing high-quality patents should be utilized while application and related patents are further expanded. In ironmaking and post-processing, greater emphasis should be placed on securing core and fundamental technologies with high technological impact. In addition, the United States and Europe may be considered as major target jurisdictions for expanding overseas patent protection because of their relatively high shares of foreign applicants.

키워드

Steel Robotics; Patent Analysis; Quantitative Analysis; Technology Market Growth Stage; Patent Filing Concentration (HHI); Patent Competitiveness; 철강 로봇; 특허 분석; 정량분석; 기술시장 성장단계; 특허출원 집중도(HHI); 기술경쟁력
제목
철강 제조공정별 특허 분석을 통한 철강 로봇기술 경쟁력 및 유망 기술영역 도출
제목 (타언어)
A Study on Identifying Competitiveness in Steelmaking Robot Technology and Promising Technology Areas through Patent Analysis by Manufacturing Process
저자
황태민; 이헌희
발행일
2026-09
유형
Y
저널명
법과정책연구
권
26
호
3
페이지
39 ~ 98