상세 보기
민법 제302조 특수지역권의 개정방향 - 일본민법 입회권(入会権) 규정의 검토를 통하여 -
초록
This study aims to propose a desirable legislative direction for amending the provisions on Special Servitude set forth in Article 302 of the Korean Civil Act. To this end, this paper examines the legislative process through which Special Servitude was incorporated into the Korean Civil Act, as well as the Korean Civil Act amendment discussions in 2004 and 2013, confirming its historical intersection with the Rights of Common under the Japanese Civil Code—including the Meiji Civil Code context—during the Japanese colonial period. Customary practices regarding Rights of Common were verified through customary survey reports, decisions of the Chosen High Court, and modern decrees from the colonial period. To address historical limitations, a comparative analysis of the provisions and academic debates on Rights of Common under the Japanese Civil Code was conducted. Under the Japanese Civil Code, Rights of Common are categorized into Rights of Common with the Nature of Co-Ownership and Rights of Common without the Nature of Co-Ownership; Special Servitude under Korean law is closely aligned with the latter, Rights of Common without the Nature of Co-Ownership. Unlike in Korea, a considerable number of rights of common still persist in Japan, serving as commons and fulfilling functions for common-pool resources and environmental conservation in modern times. In contrast, as urbanization and industrialization in Korea have reduced the practical necessity of Special Servitude, proposals for its deletion have repeatedly surfaced during Civil Act amendment attempts. However, Special Servitude possesses unique characteristics that cannot be replaced by other legal rights: First, it is a right to use and profit from another person’s land without taking possession of it. Second, such a right is held by residents of a specific area as a collective entity, and the provisions regarding collective ownership apply mutatis mutandis to the legal relations between the collective entity and its members. Third, as a source of law, customary law takes precedence over statutory law, and when following customary law, the creation, alteration, or termination of in rem rights does not require registration. Fourth, it can be established not only on the entirety of a plot of land but also on a portion thereof, and two or more collective entities may co-exist on the same land. Fifth, under the current Civil Act which lacks separate provisions for Servitude in Gross, Special Servitude embodies the practical legal nature of Servitude in Gross. While it is undeniable that the practical necessity of Special Servitude is diminishing in modern society, an actual legal substance corresponding to Special Servitude still exists in agricultural and mountainous regions. Therefore, extreme caution is required before prematurely advocating for the deletion of the relevant provision. Rather than simply abolishing Special Servitude, this paper proposes retaining the provision while amending it to reflect current realities. Ultimately, this paper suggests expanding the scope of entities eligible to hold Special Servitude and, furthermore, establishing a new chapter for Servitude in Gross in the Civil Act, thereby reclassifying Special Servitude as a special statutory provision in the form of a “Collective Servitude in Gross.”
키워드
- 제목
- 민법 제302조 특수지역권의 개정방향 - 일본민법 입회권(入会権) 규정의 검토를 통하여 -
- 제목 (타언어)
- Directions for Amending Special Servitudes under Article 302 of the Korean Civil Law: A Comparative Analysis with Rights of Common in the Japanese Civil Code
- 저자
- 양미숙
- 발행일
- 2026-09
- 유형
- Y
- 저널명
- 민사법학
- 권
- 116
- 페이지
- 159 ~ 210
- 언어
- KOR
- 출판사
- 한국민사법학회
- 발행국가
- 대한민국
- 분량
- 52 페이지
- ISSN
- P 1226-5004