칼 포퍼식 토론에 나타난 대학생의 논증 오류 양상 연구

A Study on the Operational Patterns of Argumentation Fallacies among College Students in Karl Popper Debates

초록

The purpose of this study is to analyze the process of Karl Popper debates in university general education and to empirically investigate the types and characteristics of argumentation fallacies committed by college students. For this purpose, a total of 12 debate sessions(comprising 703 argumentation units) conducted in a mandatory general education course, Reading Classics and Debate, were transcribed and analyzed. The analysis revealed a total of 252 argumentation fallacies across approximately 35.84%(252 units) of the total 703 argumentation units. Categorizing these fallacies based on their point of occurrence, ‘fallacies of evidence’(insufficient validity of data) were the most frequent at 40.08%(101 instances). This was followed by ‘fallacies of reasoning’(inappropriate connection between evidence and conclusion) at 38.10%(96 instances), and ‘fallacies of discussion’(occurring during interaction with the opponent) at 21.83%(55 instances). Regarding specific types, the most prevalent were the ‘fallacy of hasty generalization’ (20.24%), which expands isolated examples to a whole phenomenon; the ‘fallacy of causal relationship’(18.65%), which oversimplifies complex causes; and ‘missing the point’(12.30%), which evades direct questions and blurs the focus of the discussion. The core characteristics of university debaters derived from this analysis are twofold: First, the fallacies occurring during the debates did not manifest in isolation, but rather demonstrated a multi-stage chain transition where logical flaws in the preceding stage triggered subsequent errors. Second, a distinct gap was identified between the students outward proficiency in following debate procedures and their actual qualitative capacity to logically substantiate their claims with objective data. While the volume of information gathered through internet searches and generative AI has increased, their ability to critically analyze and integrate this information into a logical structure remained immature. These results suggest that future university debate education must transcend the mere transfer of rhetoric or the rote memorization of fallacy types. Accordingly, this study proposes the systematic implementation of evidence-based argumentation education to foster critical data evaluation, multidimensional reasoning training to analyze complex issues, and integrated metacognitive communication education to enable students to monitor and refine their own logical frameworks in real-time.

키워드

Karl Popper Debate; University Debate Education; Argumentation Fallacy; Fallacy of Evidence; Fallacy of Reasoning; Fallacy of Discussion; Metacognitive Communication Education; 칼 포퍼식 토론; 대학 토론 교육; 논증 오류; 근거의 오류; 추론의 오류; 논의의 오류; 메타인지 소통 교육
제목
칼 포퍼식 토론에 나타난 대학생의 논증 오류 양상 연구
제목 (타언어)
A Study on the Operational Patterns of Argumentation Fallacies among College Students in Karl Popper Debates
저자
김민정
발행일
2026-10
유형
Y
저널명
교양교육연구
권
20
호
5
페이지
373 ~ 396