경제림육성단지 산림사업의 실행조건과 저해요인에 대한 공무원 및민간 주체의 중요도-실행도 분석

Importance–Performance Analysis of Implementation Conditions and Impeding Factors for Forest Operations in Economic Forest Development Complexes as Evaluated by Forestry Officials and Private Stakeholders
  • 손은희; 
  • 성호진; 
  • 김재엽; 
  • 유자민; 
  • 김형호

초록

Economic Forest Development Complexes are designated forests managed to secure stable timber supply and demand and to promote high-quality timber production. This study compared the evaluations of forestry officials and private stakeholders on 13 conditions required for implementing forest operations in the complexes and examined differences in impediments between Regional Forest Services (RFS) and local governments (LG). Ninety officials (32 RFS and 58 LG) and 53 private stakeholders (11 professional engineers in forestry, 20 forest owners, 16 nursery operators, and 6 log producers) rated the importance and current performance of the 13 conditions on five-point scales, and importance–performance analysis (IPA) was used to derive the importance–performance gaps. Among 85 officials with complete responses, performance was lower than importance for all conditions (gaps: 0.68–1.58; p < 0.001), and owner cooperation (gap: 1.58) and harvest profitability (gap: 1.48) were the only conditions in the “concentrate here” quadrant. Profitability ranked among the four largest gaps in every private group. The conditions in the officials’ “concentrate here” quadrant were unchanged in sensitivity analyses using item-wise pairwise deletion, exclusion of straightlining respondents, and equal weighting of institutions. RFS officials most often reported site selection, and LG officials owner consultation, as the most difficult implementation stage; this difference remained significant after Benjamini–Hochberg adjustment when the analysis was restricted to respondents who reported a single stage. Forest owners attributed harvesting outside the complexes mainly to low profitability. These findings suggest that improving profitability should be accompanied by support tailored to organizational conditions, emphasizing site identification and funding for RFS and owner consultation for LG.

키워드

Economic Forest Development Complex; Forest operations; Impeding factors; Importance–performance analysis; Owner cooperation; 경제림육성단지; 산림사업; 산주 협조; 저해요인; 중요도-실행도 분석
제목
경제림육성단지 산림사업의 실행조건과 저해요인에 대한 공무원 및민간 주체의 중요도-실행도 분석
제목 (타언어)
Importance–Performance Analysis of Implementation Conditions and Impeding Factors for Forest Operations in Economic Forest Development Complexes as Evaluated by Forestry Officials and Private Stakeholders
저자
손은희; 성호진; 김재엽; 유자민; 김형호
발행일
2026-10
유형
Y
저널명
농업생명과학연구
권
60
호
5
페이지
91 ~ 103