공정거래법상 정보교환 합의 금지의 법리적 쟁점 − 2026년 시중은행 담보인정비율 정보교환 사건을 중심으로 −

A Study on the legal issues of the information exchange cartel in Korean Competition Law

초록

This paper aims to critically examine the legal issues regarding the prohibition of information exchange cartel under the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act of Korea(MRFTA), focusing on the case of loan-to-value (LTV) ratio information exchange among commercial banks. First, it outlines the LTV information exchange case and the gist of the Korea Fair Trade Commission’s (KFTC) resolution, then identifies the key legal issues (Ⅱ). Subsequently, it critically reviews the legislative purpose of the prohibition on information exchange agreements, the nature of information exchange activities, the interpretation of "transaction terms" subject to regulation, the relationship between the definition of information exchange agree- ments and the presumption of collusion, the assessment of the anti- competitive nature of such agreements, and the criteria for evaluating efficiency-enhancing effects and illegality (Ⅲ). Finally, the conclusion summarizes the discussion and offers several suggestions (Ⅳ). The main points of the discussion are as follows: First, the prohibition of information exchange agreements under Article 40(1)(9) of the MRFTA and the legal doctrine of presuming an agreement through information exchange under Article 40(5) must be strictly distinguished. Second, information exchange is a common practice among businesses in a market economy and should be viewed as neutral from the perspective of competition policy. Third, the legal requirements for information exchange agreements under the MRFTA should be seen as limiting the scope to types of exchange that can be identified as anti-competitive, and one must be cautious against overly expansive interpretations driven solely by the legislative intent to regulate such practices. Fourth, "transaction terms," one of the categories of information for which exchange is prohibited, should not be interpreted beyond the scope of their literal meaning; it is appropriate to limit them to terms directly presented to trading partners or consumers, consistent with existing interpretations and judicial precedents under the MRFTA. Fifth, legal standards for assessing the anti-competitive nature of information exchange agreements, their efficiency-enhancing effects, and their illegality need to be established with greater precision.

키워드

information exchange cartel; transactions terms; Pre- sumption of an Agreement on Information Exchange; Loan-to-Value Ratio Case; constraints of competition; Korean Competition Law; 정보교환 합의; 부당한 공동행위; 거래조건; 정보교환을 통한 합의 추정; 담보인정비율 사건
제목
공정거래법상 정보교환 합의 금지의 법리적 쟁점 − 2026년 시중은행 담보인정비율 정보교환 사건을 중심으로 −
제목 (타언어)
A Study on the legal issues of the information exchange cartel in Korean Competition Law
저자
박준영
발행일
2026-06
유형
Y
저널명
Distribution Law Review
권
13
호
1
페이지
1 ~ 46