Evaluation of Take-Over Request Lead Time Based on Driving Behavioral Interaction Between Autonomous Vehicles and Manual Vehicles

Abstract

Autonomous vehicles (AVs) at SAE Levels 3 require a take-over request to switch from autonomous to manual mode when leaving the operational design domain (ODD). An appropriate take-over request lead time (TORlt) is necessary for safe interaction between AVs and non-AVs. This study developed a methodology to derive the optimal TORlt for AVs entering the area out of the ODD using a multi-agent driving simulator experiment. The multi-criteria decision-making method was adopted to integrate evaluation indicators to derive an optimal TORlt. The TORlt was defined as 3, 6, 9, 12, and 15 s in the driving simulation experiment scenario. The driving simulation experiment was conducted with a total of 60 participants. The simulation network was a two-lane urban road in each direction with a total length of 1.7 km, including a school zone where the autonomous driving mode is prohibited. Three requirements were established to determine the optimal TORlt: minimizing the take-over time, maximizing the success rate of take-over, and minimizing the potential of rear-end collisions due to vehicle interactions. After conducting comparative analyses of individual evaluation indicators for each scenario, a multi-criteria decision-making method was used for integrated evaluation to determine the optimal TORlt. It was found that the optimal TORlt for AVs on urban roads is 9 s. The results of this study can be used as valuable fundamentals in determining take-over requests for AVs toward safer vehicle interactions in the traffic stream.